• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
    • About
    • Board of Directors
    • LWV Mission Statement
    • Bylaws of the LWVN
    • LWVN Non-Partisan Policy
    • LWVN Diversity Policy
    • LWVN Handbook
    • Annual Meetings
    • Newton League Past Presidents
    • Jane Leighton Volunteer-of-the-Year Award
    • LWVN Scholarship Program
  • News and Events
    • News & Events
    • The League Presents…
    • Newsletters
  • New Member FAQ
  • Contact Us
LWV Newton logo
  • Facebook

Visit us on Facebook!

  • Learn
    • Learn
    • The League Presents…
    • Topic Meetings
    • Newton Civics Challenge
  • Act/Advocate
    • Act/Advocate
    • LWVN Positions and Program
    • Issues We Are Following
    • LWVN Observer Corps
    • LWVN Local Action Log
    • Consensus Studies
    • National and State Positions
  • Vote
    • Vote
    • How to Register to Vote
    • How to Pick a Candidate
    • How, When and Where to Vote
    • Massachusetts Voters Bill of Rights
    • Your Elected Officials
    • Tips for Contacting Elected Officials

Stormwater Plan, Water & Stormwater Rates Make Progress

November 16, 2014

by Priscilla M. Leith

Newton administration officials and aldermen have worked hard over the summer investigating options for revising the city’s water rates and laying out a strategic plan for much needed capital improvements to our stormwater system. Newton CFO Maureen Lemieux and DPW Commissioner David Turocy presented detail at October 1 and November 5 meetings of the aldermanic Public Facilities Committee. (For an informative introduction to these topics, see Water Underground, an article by Ald. Deb Crossley in the fall 2014 issue of the Newton Conservators Newsletter.)

Newton has separate accounts called Enterprise Funds from which the city pays the Mass Water Resources Authority (MWRA) for fresh water and sewer service, as well as the cost of the city’s internal stormwater system, which diverts street runoff into local rivers, streams and Crystal Lake. Residents receive quarterly bills for sewer and water service that vary by usage, but a flat stormwater charge is attached to quarterly tax bills. Revenues from stormwater fees — $25/quarter for residential and $150/quarter for commercial use – are inadequate to maintain the system as required. These fees need to be raised after more work is done by a Working Group consisting of aldermen and administration personnel.

Water Use

Water use is measured at each residence and each commercial property. Sewer use is not measured, as there is no known way to do this, so sewer charges are based on water use at the property. A careful analysis by the Working Group reveals the following:

  • 80% of water customers use < 125 hundred cubic feet (HCF) per year (1 HCF = 748 gallons)
  • 63% of water customers use < 90 HCF per year

Under our current 3-tiered water rates:

  • 80% pay < $2,000 per year
  • 44% pay between $1,000 and $2,000 per year
  • 36% pay < $1,000 per year

Put another way, the “average” household uses 25 HCF of water and pays $608/quarter for water and $896/quarter for sewer, for a total of $1,504/quarter, or $6,016/year.

Our water Budget is $22M annually and our sewer budget is $32M annually.

Options

The Working Group arrived at three options:  1) charge a fixed fee + cost for usage; 2) charge a single rate for everyone; or 3) devise a tiered structure. They recommend the primary considerations be providing sufficient resources for utilities operations and fairness to rate payers – ie, payment for services rendered. Secondary are sensitivity to small users and promotion of water conservation.

The first option would amount to $312/residence for water and $531/residence for sewer, for a total of $843/residence for the fixed fee and then a variable amount for usage. This choice would harm all of Newton’s small users.

The second option, using a single rate of $7.12/HCF for water and $10.36/HCF for sewer to cover estimated costs of MRWA services, would bring both winners and losers. Commercial customers use the most water, and their bills would go down. All other rates would go up except those using large amounts of water. This is unfair and also discourages conservation.

The third option is the best solution, because it promotes conservation and covers capital costs.

Proposed water/sewer rate structure, by tiers

Water %Incr Sewer % Incr
0-10 HCF’s  $5.50 –  $ 9.25 –
11-25 HCF’s  6.40  16%  10.75  16%
26-60 HCF’s  7.70  20%  12.90  20%
>60 HCF’s  9.25  20%  15.50  20%
Irrigation (of yards and lawns)  9.00

 

Residents who are considering going to the last tier would have to install a second meter connected to their outdoor watering system. They would contract with a plumber to install the meter and plumb necessary lines, with the utilities division inspecting and approving the installation. The estimated cost is $750. A calculator will be put on the city’s website so any user can put his/her data in and figure out if an outside watering system is worthwhile. For a household using < 25 HCF per year of outdoor water, the payback period will be 3 years. If people wish to do this, they will have to notify the city of their intent to do so by April 1, 2015. The rates would then take effect on July 1st following installation. Until we know how many people will install second meters, the rates will not be final, and of course there will be a public hearing before aldermen vote on the rates.

Stormwater runoff

Stormwater runoff is a different situation. Current stormwater fees of $25/year for residential and $150/year for commercial properties are not covering the costs. And properties that have impervious pavement (parking lots, sidewalks, driveways, etc.) are costing the city more. People who are water their yards or have a lawn sprinkler system have that water included in calculating their sewer bills. This is thought to be unfair and environmentally unsound. Water put into yards or lawns gets filtered naturally and goes into the groundwater supply, which is good.

The stormwater budget now supports a 6-person crew that is routinely augmented by Sewer Division personal. Stormwater expenses use up all the funds generated with none left for capital improvements. Complying with new EPA regulations, when Newton has to renew its EPA permit, will increase the city’s stormwater system costs. We know we need capital improvements to abate localized flooding, to do stream maintenance, and to do culvert maintenance. In summary, the city must generate additional revenue to pay for an adequate stormwater system.

 

Recommendations

Recommendations are that Newton switch to a fee based on a property’s impervious surfaces. An impervious surface is any material or structure on or above ground that prevents water from going back into the underlying soil – e.g. sidewalks, roof tops, parking lots, driveways…

 

Proposed rate structure:

  • Each residence would pay $60
  • Each commercial property would pay $25/extra ERU (Equivalent Residential Unit).
  • 1 ERU = 2,600 square feet
  • Each tax-exempt property would pay $25/extra ERU

However, CFO Maureen Lemieux advised that the system of charging by amount of impervious surface is “on hold” by the State. Also, Newton’s data is over 9 years old, so she does not want to use this data. The Law Department is consulting with the state Department of Revenue as to what other system we can use. Since we cannot go by eru’s this year or next year, Lemieux’s recommendation is to plan for 2016 to propose that system, after Newton can commission for new data to be collected. Consensus was to do that, but meanwhile to use the current simple fees and raise them to cover the costs of maintenance for the next two fiscal years. The Law Department will be asked to draft an ordinance using tiers.

Aldermen will continue discussions on this during November and December. A public hearing will be held before rates re voted on. The new charges will eventually appear on bills sent out to property owners for FY2014-2015.

Categories: Environmental Issues

Primary Sidebar

Support LWVN

Join/Renew
Donate

Election Info

The State Primary is Tuesday, September 6.  Don't forget to VOTE!

  • Register to vote
  • How to Vote
  • Find your polling location
  • Absentee Ballots

Upcoming Events

  • There are no upcoming events.

2021 LWVN Member Handbook

An electronic version LWVN Member Handbook is now available.  Expect an updated handbook for 2022-23 in the late Fall.

LWV Mass. & US

LWV MA LWV US

Watch “The League Presents…”

The League Presents... is a monthly program on NewTV produced and directed by LWVN members about issues important to our community.

  • The League Presents: A conversation with Carol Moore, Newton’s City Clerk and Clerk of the City Council
  • The League Presents: Zoning Redesign, part 1
  • The League Presents: Newton’s Citizens Commission on Energy
  • The League Presents: What it means to be a League of Women Voters member
  • The League Presents: A Conversation with Three New School Committee Members

All past programs

Take Action & Contact Your Legislators

  • Support An Act Promoting Community Immunity
  • Support Public Health Measures 
  • Support Racial and Gender Parity
  • Take Action on the Votes Act
  • Potential Cuts to MBTA Service

Posts by Category

  • VOTE – Voters Service
    • Elections
    • Candidate Forums
    • Voter Registration
  • LEARN – Topics of Interest
    • Charter Commission
    • Community Preservation
    • Education
    • Environmental Issues
    • Housing
    • Land Use
    • Municipal Finance
    • Transportation
    • Women’s Suffrage
  • ACT – Action & Advocacy
    • Local Action Log
    • Consensus Studies – MA
    • Consensus Studies – Newton
    • Consensus Studies – US
  • City of Newton Info
    • City Council Meetings: Docket Digest
    • Observer Notes

Facebook Posts

Ellen Auerbach Grody
Ellen Auerbach Grody

June 28th, 11:33 am

Thank you for the recent letter to the mayor:LWVN Board Concurs with Newton Citizens Commission on Energy’s Memo Rejecting Newton Cemetery’s Tree Removal RequestJune 24, 2022On June 24, 2022, LWVN sent an email to Mayor Fuller expressing our our agreement with the Newton Citizens Commission on Energy (NCCE)’s memo of June 20th stating “We are writing to you regarding the Newton Cemetery’ request for exemption from the Tree Preservation Ordinance. We urge you to stand with the Director of Urban Forestry in denying that request and any waiver of its consequences. We also urge you to ask the City Council to revise the ordinance language to clarify their intent that the Tree Preservation Ordinance not exclude any property owners from its provisions.” ... See MoreSee Less
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

June 22nd, 6:26 pm

Breaking News: Governor Baker Signs VOTES Act Into Law - https://mailchi.mp/56363aee24bf/votes_act_update-8901645 ... See MoreSee Less

Breaking News: Governor Baker Signs VOTES Act Into Law

mailchi.mp

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

June 21st, 11:26 am

Newton Public Facilities Meeting: New Pipelines and Gas Valve Safety - https://mailchi.mp/ceafe522986a/newton-public-facilities-meeting-new-pipelines-and-gas-valve-safety ... See MoreSee Less

Newton Public Facilities Meeting: New Pipelines and Gas Valve Safety

mailchi.mp

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

June 13th, 10:33 am

LWVN has launched an important new "Municipal Transparency and Accountability Initiative". Learn more here!: https://lwvnewton.org/2022/06/… ... See MoreSee Less

Municipal Transparency and Accountability Initiative: Mission Statement and Goals - League of Women Voters Newton

lwvnewton.org

Throughout its 102-year history, the League of Women Voters has been a vigorous advocate for transparent and accountable government. The League strongly believes that transparency and accountability i...
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

June 9th, 10:12 am

Important Update: VOTES ACT Released from Conference Committee - https://mailchi.mp/6365b29fa297/votes_act_update ... See MoreSee Less

Important Update: VOTES ACT Released from Conference Committee

mailchi.mp

Boston, MA — The Massachusetts VOTES Act Conference Committee today released its version of the comprehensive election reform bill, which will now head to the House and Senate for final procedural...
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The League of Women Voters is a nonpartisan political organization encouraging the informed and active participation of citizens in government. It influences public policy through education and advocacy.

© 2022 League of Women Voters® Newton | P.O. Box 610207, Newton, MA 02461 | info@lwvnewton.org

Site by Tech-Tamer | Log in