• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
    • About
    • Board of Directors
    • LWV Mission Statement
    • Bylaws of the LWVN
    • LWVN Non-Partisan Policy
    • LWVN Diversity Policy
    • LWVN Handbook
    • Annual Meetings
    • Newton League Past Presidents
    • Jane Leighton Volunteer-of-the-Year Award
    • LWVN Scholarship Program
  • News and Events
    • News & Events
    • The League Presents…
    • Newsletters
  • New Member FAQ
  • Contact Us
LWV Newton logo
  • Facebook

Visit us on Facebook!

  • Learn
    • Learn
    • The League Presents…
    • Topic Meetings
    • Newton Civics Challenge
  • Act/Advocate
    • Act/Advocate
    • LWVN Positions and Program
    • Issues We Are Following
    • LWVN Observer Corps
    • LWVN Local Action Log
    • Consensus Studies
    • National and State Positions
  • Vote
    • Vote
    • How to Register to Vote
    • How, When and Where to Vote
    • How to Pick a Candidate
    • Massachusetts Voters Bill of Rights
    • Your Elected Officials
    • Tips for Contacting Elected Officials

Charter Commission Meeting 2-1-17

February 5, 2017

Charter Commission Meeting

February 1, 2017

Attending:  Josh Krintzman (Chair), Jane Frantz, Howard Haywood, Anne Larner, Karen Manning, Chris Steele

Tardy:  Rhanna Kidwell (Vice Chair, 7:25 pm)), Bryan Barash (7:10 pm)

Approval of January 25th Minutes:  Approved with minor changes.

Public Comments: 

Nancy Tenor:  Last night CC members presented to Ward 6 Newton Dems.  Appreciates time and good intentions.  Felt intention was less than convincing…would vote no if voted today.  First, proposed term limits—already have them in elections.  Why force a capable and skilled office holder out?  Second, proposed 12-member council—why shrink representation to 12 people—they are twice as far from electorate.  Not be able to represent diversity in city.  Third, city-wide councilors—subsumed to the tyranny of the majority.  Wants to vote for own councilor in own ward and connect with person as they go door-to-door.  Wide ranging discussion is needed—waste vs. deliberation?

Howard Shrut:  resident in Newton for 69 years, rather apolitical; shrinking the size of the Board of Aldermen rubs him the wrong way.  Having ward councilors is more personal—Newton is made up of neighborhoods—gives you a sense of closeness of who’s going to represent you.  Smaller is a coterie and less democratic body.  Would vote for old method rather than the new.

Sallee Lipshutz:  where was presentation made and who made it?  Josh:  Newton Dems—4 members there?  Not in violation of open meeting, weren’t deliberating.  Discussion about whether or not or how to make meetings public.

Nathaniel Lichten:  Article 2—transition provisions.  Thanks for taking comments seriously.  Still have a couple of concerns.  Looked up influence on state government website—saw only one reference to lobbyists.  Dictionary definition—quoted.  In the absence of some more specific interpretation—means to effect or sway or impel to action.  This would include public comment, meetings behind the scenes, a parent talking to a principal.  Be very, very careful about restricting the rights of people who volunteer for the city who are acting beyond the scope of their volunteer duties.  Many work on very narrow issues—i.e. Angino Farm volunteer should not be barred from contacting a principal or superintendent since it’s not their role.

George Mansfield:  attended the Ward 6 meeting last night.  Appreciated presentation and discussion.  His position on article 2 has not changed, and neither has the Charter Commission.  Thinks it would be unfortunate if the recommendations and the whole of the charter were carried on the vote by recommendnations in Article 2, specifically changes to Ward Councilors.  He’s played that role—it has a real place in the city and has for 150 years in the culture, structure and governing of the city.  Doesn’t believe that comments will change recommendation, but does have to say that he will find himself in a position of opposing the charter vote in November.  When this comes up for a vote at a regular city election, there are going to be seats for the next term not affected by the charter (which will take effect in 2020).  Already there is evidence that people who hold Ward Councilor seats will run at large to avoid having seat taken away.  Can’t see any reason that someone would run for Ward Councilor—only hold seat for two years.  Different from running for Charter Commission, which is limited in scope.  He wouldn’t run for seat that lasts only two years on City Council.  Also:  looked at public presentation on website—slide that says the benefits of reducing the size of the City Council—1st benefit is that reduces the size of the Board.  Thinks should not have that there.  He feels that is likely to reduce transparency, accountability and responsiveness.  Would be much lower with a smaller board.

Jen Abbot:  Personally feel that reducing the size of the Board is a great benefit and would increase responsiveness and accountability.  Would increase some competition.  If larger council were more responsive, then we would see them all over the state.  Newton is an outlier.  Strongly in support of work and seems really well-researched.  Other great benefits.  Not being able to vote for all that represent her in a place the size of Newton is very troubling.  Every voter will have a voice in choosing.

Review Clean Draft of Charter: 

Discussion on the following topics:

  • What does full council mean? What about quorum? Majority and two-thirds are based on the number then in office.
  • Section 11-2b—what mean by “influence?” What is undue influence and what is proper advocacy?  Tonya from Collins Center presented more specific language from Oakland, CA.  Discussion about whether part b clarifies or makes things more vague.  Discussion of whether or not there is value in keeping this section in the charter—reaffirm concerns about conflict of interest and gives a value statement?    Motion to remove 11-2b fails.  Motion that tweaks the proposal—motion fails with a 4-4 vote.  More tweaking, some removing of language…all trying to get to a clear language on what influence should not be allowed, but not to replicate what is in the state law.  New motion with slightly different language:  passed 5-3.
  • Section 11-2c—add “appointed” office?
  • Section 10-3—change another ”may” to “shall”. Some concern over Section 10-3 a and b: concern about confusion from the language in “a.”  Concern in “b” from David Olson about petitions.  Members will look at it before vote in 2 weeks.
  • Section 3-10 on permanent vacancy in the office of Mayor—add a line that/ succession order could be determined by ordinance? Wasn’t resolved from last meeting.  Add language that if the President of the Council is unwilling or unable to serve, then the Vice-President, and if not, the Council will choose among its members.  Motion made and passed.
  • Section 5-2—just confirming changes, which are slightly different from notes. Need to keep in “all funds subject to appropriation.”
  • Section 12-7m—recommending insertion of “Council” to resolutions. No preference…
  • Back to Section 11-2c—what about if someone advocated for removal of someone from a position? Add “unduly?”  yes…

Read it carefully and will go through again in 2 weeks.

Review Draft of Preliminary Report: 

New version adds rationale for major changes, specifically the changes to the City Council and to term limits.  Changes came rather late this week, so go through tonight with general requests.  The members went through the document sentence-by-sentence, making some changes in preparation to review the final draft in two weeks.

Respectfully submitted by Sue Flicop (who left at 9:45 pm with the review still going on.)

 

Categories: Charter Commission, Local Action Log, Observer Notes

Primary Sidebar

Support LWVN

Join/Renew
Donate

Upcoming Events

Apr 30
4:00 PM - 6:00 PM

Our Civics Challenge is Returning!

Jun 10
9:00 AM - 4:00 PM

LWVMA 2023 State Convention

Jun 15
6:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Save the Date! Annual Meeting 2023

View Calendar

LWV Mass. & US

LWV MA LWV US

Watch “The League Presents…”

The League Presents... is a monthly program on NewTV produced and directed by LWVN members about issues important to our community.

  • The League Presents: Newton Food Pantries Update
  • The League Presents: School Buildings and the Override, with Josh Morse, Newton Public Building Commissioner
  • The League Presents: City of Newton Override 2023

All past programs

Take Action & Contact Your Legislators

  • Support An Act Promoting Community Immunity
  • Support Public Health Measures 
  • Support Racial and Gender Parity
Cover for League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
428
League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

The League registers voters and educates them about the important issues and challenges facing Newto

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA updated their cover photo.

2 months ago

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
League of Women Voters of Newton, MA's cover photo ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

2 months ago

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
Newton voters now have the option to vote early by mail in all elections, with no excuse required! All registered voters in Newton should have received their official 2023 Vote by Mail Application this week, in plenty of time to Vote by Mail in the Newton Special Election on the override proposal. Full details of how to vote by mail are here: www.newtonma.gov/government/elections/absentee-voting ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

2 months ago

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
Join us for a conversation with Congressman Jake Auchincloss of the MA 4th District on Wednesday, Feb 15 at 7:30pm!Learn more at lwvnewton.org/event/congressmanauchincloss-feb2023/Register at bit.ly/talk-with-jake ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

2 months ago

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
LWVN is again offering two scholarships to high school seniors in Newton! We are pleased to have increased our scholarship award for the class of 2023 to $2,000 each!Learn more at lwvnewton.org/lwvn-scholarship-program/Candidates should apply online at bit.ly/LWVNAPPLY23 Deadline extended to March 31, 2023! ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA

5 months ago

League of Women Voters of Newton, MA
Election Day is one week away! Not sure what's on the ballot or how to vote in the midterm elections? Get your election questions answered at www.vote411.org and watch forums on the 4 Massachusetts ballot questions at lwvma.org/ballot-question-forums/ ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The League of Women Voters is a nonpartisan political organization encouraging the informed and active participation of citizens in government. It influences public policy through education and advocacy.

© 2023 League of Women Voters® Newton | P.O. Box 610207, Newton, MA 02461 | info@lwvnewton.org

Site by Tech-Tamer | Log in